Best Aftershaves for Men 2024: Top Picks for Every Skin Type

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

Navigating the vast sea of grooming products, finding the best aftershaves for men in 2024 can feel like a daunting task.

You’re not just looking for a quick fix; you’re seeking mastery over your grooming routine, innovation in your skincare, and control over how you present yourself to the world.

Whether you’re battling razor burn, seeking to soothe sensitive skin, or aiming for a moisturized and refreshed face, this guide has got you covered.

Dive into our top picks tailored for every skin type, and elevate your post-shave experience to new heights.

8 Best Aftershaves for Men

When it comes to finding the perfect aftershave, you’re in luck with the top picks for 2024.

Whether you’re aiming to soothe sensitive skin, moisturize, or simply enjoy a refreshing scent, there’s something for every preference and skin type.

Let’s explore these standout options to keep your skin feeling great and smelling even better.

1. Proraso After Shave Lotion Refreshing Toning

View On Amazon
If you’re after a refreshing finish to your shaving routine, Proraso After Shave Lotion is a standout choice. Tailored for sensitive skin, it merges the calming effects of a balm with the moisture of a cream, offering instant relief.

Its natural oatmeal and green tea ingredients work wonders on inflamed skin, minus the harsh chemicals. The menthol scent is invigorating yet subtle, leaving your skin soft and revitalized.

2. Art of Shaving Sandalwood After Shave

View On Amazon
Next up, let’s dive into the Art of Shaving Sandalwood After Shave, a game-changer for your post-shave routine. Imagine wrapping your skin in a blanket of moisture that not only soothes but also revitalizes.

This non-greasy balm, infused with natural jojoba seed oil and shea butter, works wonders in reducing irritation and promoting skin healing. Its subtle scent won’t overpower your senses, making it the perfect choice for those who appreciate understated elegance.

A small dab goes a long way, ensuring your skin stays conditioned and firm without the fuss.

3. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

View On Amazon
The Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel stands out as a top choice for men seeking relief and care for their skin post-shave. Its alcohol-free, fragrance-free formula is packed with natural ingredients like Aloe, Sage, and Lavender, offering a soothing touch to irritated skin without causing further dryness or discomfort.

This gel is particularly beneficial for those with sensitive skin, as it calms razor burn and reduces redness effectively. Its lightweight texture ensures it absorbs quickly, leaving no greasy residue behind.

While it’s on the pricier side and might be hard to find in stores, its quality and effectiveness make it a worthy investment for a superior post-shave experience.

4. Bay Rum Aftershave Splash Men Dominica

View On Amazon
Indulge in the handcrafted Bay Rum Aftershave Splash, a concoction that’s as invigorating as it’s soothing. Made in the USA with all-natural ingredients, this aftershave is a treat for your skin, free from synthetic chemicals and artificial colors.

Its unique blend of exotic spices, citrus, essential oils, and extracts, combined with 100% pure glycerin, ensures your skin is re-moisturized and toned without feeling overly tight. The classic Bay Rum scent, with a modern twist of cinnamon, allspice, vanilla, and clove, will awaken your senses and firm your skin, fading after about 20 minutes to avoid overpowering your presence.

5. Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm

View On Amazon
Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm is your go-to for a soothing post-shave experience. It’s packed with Vitamin E, Chamomile, and Witch Hazel extracts to combat the common irritations of shaving, like burning and dryness.

You’ll appreciate its quick absorption and the fact that it leaves no greasy residue, making it perfect for all skin types. Plus, it’s alcohol-free, so you can expect a gentle touch with just a hint of fragrance.

Ideal for daily use, this balm comes in a practical three-pack, each bottle holding 3.3 fluid ounces, ensuring you’re covered for the long haul. It’s also a thoughtful choice for a stocking stuffer, especially if you’re replacing a discontinued favorite like the Neutrogena product.

6. Baxter California After Shave Balm Cooling

View On Amazon
In your quest for mastery over your grooming routine, consider the Baxter California After Shave Balm Cooling as your ally. This balm is a game-changer with its non-greasy, matte finish that absorbs quickly, leaving your skin soothed and refreshed.

Enriched with aloe vera and allantoin, it’s designed to moisturize without drying out your skin, while also preventing ingrown hairs and razor burn. The menthol scent provides a cooling and refreshing sensation, making it a pleasant experience post-shave.

Although it’s on the pricier side, a small dab goes a long way, with one tube lasting almost six months, making it a worthwhile investment for your skin’s comfort and health.

7. Barbershop Aftershave for Men

View On Amazon
Next up, let’s dive into the Barbershop Aftershave for Men. This gem packs a punch with its non-greasy formula, ensuring your skin stays moisturized and nourished without feeling oily. Its durable pump cap makes application a breeze, and at 4.48 ounces, it’s the perfect size for your grooming kit.

The scent? Subtle yet distinctly masculine, offering a crisp, clean aroma that’s a fresh departure from traditional barbershop scents. It’s a fantastic pick for those looking to reduce razor burn and prevent irritation, all while keeping their skin feeling refreshed.

8. Lucky Tiger Face Tonic After Shave

View On Amazon
Lucky Tiger Face Tonic After Shave is an 8-ounce liquid that offers a clean, light citrus fragrance. It serves as both an aftershave and face tonic, soothing razor burn and moisturizing your skin effectively.

This non-greasy formula absorbs well without causing a burning sensation, making it suitable for all skin types.

Soothing Sensitive Skin

If you’re looking to calm and comfort your sensitive skin after shaving, selecting the right aftershave is crucial.

Products with natural ingredients like Oatmeal and Green Tea are known for their soothing properties, helping to reduce redness and irritation.

Opting for alcohol-free formulations can also be beneficial, as they tend to be gentler and less drying on delicate skin.

Oatmeal and Green Tea Ingredients

When it comes to soothing sensitive skin after a shave, the combination of oatmeal and green tea in your aftershave can be a game-changer.

These natural ingredients are known for their calming sensations and anti-inflammatory effects, making them perfect for men who experience irritation or redness post-shave.

Oatmeal, with its gentle formula, provides a soothing touch, while green tea offers antioxidant properties that protect and refresh the skin.

Together, they create an aftershave that not only calms but also revitalizes your skin, catering to every skin type with their nurturing embrace.

Alcohol-Free Formulations

Building on the importance of natural ingredients like oatmeal and green tea for soothing sensitive skin, it’s crucial to consider alcohol-free formulations in your aftershave choices.

• Sensitive Skin Friendly: Alcohol-free aftershaves are less likely to cause irritation or redness, making them ideal for those with sensitive skin.
• Moisturizing Benefits: These formulations often include hydrating ingredients, providing the moisture your skin needs without the drying effects of alcohol.
• Healing Properties: Without the sting of alcohol, these aftershaves can help in the healing process, reducing the risk of razor burns and bumps.
• Non-Greasy Finish: Many alcohol-free options are designed to absorb quickly, leaving your skin feeling refreshed and non-greasy.

Choosing the best aftershave for men means considering your skin’s needs for moisturizing, healing, and a non-greasy finish, especially if you have sensitive skin. Alcohol-free aftershaves offer a gentle yet effective solution, ensuring your post-shave experience is both soothing and revitalizing.

Moisturizing and Healing

When it comes to aftershaves, the key to a soothing and healing post-shave experience lies in the ingredients.

Natural oils and butters, along with glycerin, are your best allies in re-moisturizing the skin. These components not only help to calm irritation and reduce redness but also ensure your skin remains hydrated and nourished, preventing the tight, dry feeling often associated with shaving.

Natural Oils and Butters

When it comes to aftershave, natural oils and butters like jojoba seed oil and shea butter are your allies, offering anti-aging properties and skin-firming effects. These ingredients ensure your skincare routine isn’t just about looking good, but also about nourishing and healing your skin.

A concentrated formula with these elements can make your aftershave a powerful addition to your grooming arsenal.

Ingredient	Benefit	Product
Jojoba Seed Oil	Hydrates and soothes skin, non-acnegenic	Art of Shaving Sandalwood After Shave
Shea Butter	Moisturizes, anti-inflammatory, aids in healing	Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm
Glycerin	Re-moisturizes, maintains hydration	Bay Rum Aftershave Splash Men Dominica
Vitamin E	Antioxidant, supports skin repair	Baxter California After Shave Balm Cooling
Witch Hazel	Reduces inflammation, soothes razor burn	Lucky Tiger Face Tonic After Shave

Glycerin for Re-moisturization

After exploring the benefits of natural oils and butters, it’s crucial to dive into the role of glycerin in aftershaves.

Glycerin, a powerhouse for skin hydration, combats skin dryness effectively. Its ability to draw moisture from the air directly into your skin ensures that your post-shave experience isn’t just about looking good but feeling great too.

This ingredient’s magic lies in its re-moisturization capabilities, providing a soothing barrier that keeps your skin hydrated long after the shave. Incorporating glycerin into your aftershave routine can significantly enhance the product’s moisturizing benefits, making it an essential component in men’s grooming for maintaining healthy, resilient skin.

Refreshing and Toning

If you’re looking for an aftershave that invigorates as it tones, options with a menthol scent might be just what you need. These products often combine the cooling sensation of menthol with the astringent properties of toners to leave your skin feeling refreshed.

For those who prefer a warmer, more exotic aroma, citrus and spice blends offer a distinctive scent that can energize your post-shave routine.

Menthol Scented Options

For those who love a refreshing kick in their grooming routine, menthol-scented aftershaves are a game-changer. They not only invigorate the skin but also leave you feeling revitalized and ready to tackle the day.

• Cooling Sensation: The menthol concentration delivers an immediate cooling effect, perfect for calming the skin post-shave.
• Scent Intensity: These aftershaves strike the right balance, offering a fragrance that’s noticeable yet not overpowering.
• Skin Sensitivity: Formulated with skin sensitivity in mind, they’re designed to refresh without irritation.
• Fragrance Preference: Whether you lean towards a subtle hint or a stronger menthol blast, there’s an option to match your fragrance preference.

Choosing a menthol-scented aftershave means embracing both innovation and mastery in your skincare routine, ensuring your skin feels as good as it looks.

Citrus and Spice Blends

For those who appreciate the allure of exotic ingredients and a fragrance that commands attention, citrus and spice blends in aftershaves offer a refreshing and toning experience.

These blends combine the crisp scent of citrus with the warm, masculine fragrance of spices, providing a unique aroma that revitalizes the skin.

Ideal for the modern man seeking innovation in his grooming routine, these aftershaves not only awaken the senses but also ensure skin revitalization.

The clean aroma of citrus paired with the depth of spices creates a balanced scent profile that’s both invigorating and soothing, making it among the best aftershaves for men who desire a distinctive, yet not overpowering fragrance.

Non-Greasy Formulas

When it comes to aftershaves, finding a formula that’s quick to absorb and leaves a matte finish without any greasiness is key for a comfortable post-shave experience.

You’ll appreciate products that hydrate and protect your skin without leaving behind a shiny or sticky residue. These non-greasy formulas are perfect for keeping your skin feeling refreshed and looking its best after every shave.

Quick Absorption

When it comes to aftershave for men, especially those with sensitive skin, quick absorption is a game-changer.

Alcohol-based options, while effective in disinfection, can sometimes be drying. However, many modern formulations have cleverly balanced this with moisturizing ingredients, ensuring your skin feels refreshed, not parched.

Scented options add a pleasant touch to the ritual, leaving you not just feeling good but smelling great too. Whether it’s the cooling sensation of menthol or the subtle warmth of sandalwood, the right aftershave turns a daily chore into a moment of self-care.

Opt for products that cater to all skin types, including sensitive ones, to ensure your post-shave experience is soothing and invigorating.

Matte-Finish Balms

When it comes to aftershave balms, finding the right one that doesn’t leave your skin feeling greasy is key.

Matte-finish balms are the go-to for a non-greasy feel, catering to various skin types including dry, oily, combination, and those prone to ingrown hairs. These balms are formulated with natural ingredients that respect your skin sensitivity and fragrance preferences.

They’re designed to absorb quickly, leaving your skin moisturized without the shine.

Price considerations are important, but investing in a quality aftershave balm can make all the difference in your post-shave routine, ensuring your skin feels refreshed and well-cared for.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)