10 Best Aftershaves for Men All Skin Types 2023

1. Proraso Aftershave Lotion

Made in Italy from a company founded in 1908, this product falls into a real classic aftershave category.

Proraso Aftershave Lotion has been the go-to product for men all over the world for years.

However, don’t be fooled by the name of (lotion); as we explained in the aftershave section above, aftershave lotions look more like splashing versus a creamy balm after shaving.

So if you are one of those guys who love the burning, tingling sensation you get from a high-quality aftershave, you’ll like it.

Proraso gives a touch of menthol to their aftershave, both of which provide a refreshing coolness to the face.

You will also benefit from the purifying properties of the eucalyptus and astringent properties of the witch hazel.

It is 100% free of parabens, artificial colors, silicones, mineral oils, and other unwanted substances, and it will earn you a million dollars if you are part of your skincare program.

The manufacturers declare that this is for (all skin types’). I would doubt that.

Although there is no doubt that this is peppered with excellent natural moisturizers, it does contain alcohol. And quite a lot of it.

So if you have dry skin, this is not an aftershave to choose from. Simply because the skin cells that are not yet hydrated will be dehydrated further by the alcohol content, and your acid mantle will be removed, which would have worked as a natural moisturizer.

2. Duke Cannon Cooling Aftershave Balm

When it comes to the best aftershave balm for men, the Duke Cannon Cooling Aftershave Balm can never be ignored.

This aftershave balm is not only made from natural oils and ingredients that provide hydration and prevent redness and burns but is also affordable compared with other high-quality aftershaves out there. This is what we particularly liked about this aftershave:

One of the main reasons men prefer Duke Cannon Cooling Aftershave Balm over other products is because of its great fragrance. This aftershave has a light scent of sandalwood and bergamot that is not only delicious. Your nostrils look like something unique and special, but you also feel handsome, confident, and smells like a man.

The Duke Cannon Cooling Aftershave Balm contains menthol, which provides instant relief with an extraordinary chilling effect that will make you feel like you just planted your face in an Alaskan snowdrift, so if you’re one of those guys who have hates the tingling, burning sensation, you get from an alcohol-based aftershave, then this is the product for you.

Unlike most aftershaves out there, the Duke CannonCooling Aftershave Balm is suitable for use on all skin types because it contains no harmful synthetic ingredients and a careful selection of natural ingredients such as allantoin, tea tree, aloe, and shea butter, which provides excellent hydration to the skin and minimizes irritation. A variety of extracts and oils, such as the tamanu oil and baobab oil, which is rich in essential fatty acids, along with vitamins C, A, D, and F, which nourish your skin, relieve aging, and repair skin damage from shaving.

3. Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm

The Art of Shaving is, without a doubt, one of our favorite male care companies and produces an extensive line of excellent shaving creams, pre-shave oils, and other related products.

They even made our list with the best shaving cream for men.

These guys know what they are doing when it comes to high-quality shaving, and their aftershave balms continue this pattern of excellence.

It comes in a nice thick glass bottle of 3, 4 oz with a great aesthetic, but you may get the last bit of balm out of the bottle after shaving.

If you have susceptible skin, I recommend that you use an unscented version, because even the essential oils that the different scents offer can irritate the most sensitive skin.

These balms are alcohol-free, so they do not dry out your skin and are non-comedogenic, so it does not block the pores and does not cause acne or other skin problems.

The shea butter and glycerin are excellent for hydrating your skin during the day, while the addition of vitamin C revitalizes and nourishes your skin and repairs the damage caused by shaving.

It also has a variety of other oils and extracts that improve your skin elasticity and help relieve the signs of aging.

This shaving balm is made with dry skin in mind, although it is undoubtedly also an excellent choice for sensitive skin.

Thanks to the alcohol content of 0%, your skin cells will no longer dry out due to the diuretic properties of alcohol. It is also free of antiseptic and artificial colorants, making it ideal for sensitive skin.

A large selection of moisturizers (completely natural) is a crucial element in the success of this aftershave, but it is the large amount of sandalwood oil that makes this aftershave so refreshing and moisturizing.

4. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

We should all strive to get the best possible shave every time we step in front of the bathroom mirror or grab our razor while standing in the shower. Like everything else in life, we may not always be in charge.

Whatever the reason is: lack of attention, a blunt razor, fatigue: your shave becomes a battlefield in which the skin on your face loses every time. Nicks. Cut. Razor bumps.

But not everything is lost. A high-quality aftershave saves an otherwise bleak experience, and Jack Black’s Post Shave Cooling Gel brings you back on track. It is an alcohol-free, calming lotion that wins the battle against shaving fire, redness, and irritation from shaving. Better yet, it doesn’t hurt. It does not sting your face like other aftershaves, and who needs extra discomfort after an uncomfortable shave?

Jack Black’s Post Shave Cooling Gel has a cooling effect that closes your pores after your shave and soothes what feels like a hornet nest on your face.

It contains aloe extracts, and we all know how beneficial aloe is in the treatment of irritated skin. Chamomile and witch hazel also help calm your face.

The Post Shave Cooling Gel also contains lavender oil, which has antiseptic properties that help the skin heal after a rough shave. It even helps to reduce the pain and redness caused by sunburn.

Reviewers and daily shavers also like that you only have to apply a small amount to your face to get all the benefits.

5. Bay Rum Aftershave by Barbary Coast Shave Co.

Barberry Coast is one of the many different companies that produce the once-popular companies (Bay Rum aftershaves), but don’ dare to group them all the same as the aftershave of the Barbary Coast above the rest.

Although you can expect a bottle of 4 ounces to cost a few extra dollars than others, we think the price is worth it for one of the best aftershave lotion, all-natural handmade aftershaves on the market.

Suitable for vegans and without GMOs, synthetic chemicals, or artificial colors, this is as natural as you can get.

As you may know, we are strong proponents of natural products because of their superior performance, health benefits, and environmental friendliness.

Better yet, it contains pure glycerin to nourish the skin and eliminate the drying effects that most alcohol-based aftershaves have.

Splashes are suitable for oily or healthy skin.

That’s because their alcohol content can evaporate, which is low on moisture when your skin is dry and can neutralize the valuable protective oils needed to help sensitive skin.

This is probably the most classically smelling aftershave on our list, and in fact, the laurel scent is the oldest of all aftershave scents.

But a lot is happening too! It contains orange, rum, wood, cinnamon, and many other tones that dominate and fade at different times of the day. It is, therefore, possible that you are having problems matching it with an existing Cologne.

6. NIVEA Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm

From the very striking brand, Nivea comes this balm that provides soothing relief after shaving. The Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm takes the price of the best value because this single purchase comes with three bottles.

Ingredients in this formula are witch hazel, vitamin E, chamomile, and various other natural ingredients, all of which work together to calm the skin against irritation caused by shaving. Moreover, this formula has been specially developed for sensitive skin and has been dermatologically tested to prove this.

This is a product if you want your skin to look healthier, especially if you’re going to improve your skin’s overall texture.

In general, it is a great solution to combat skin irritation, bumps, redness, or itching, and it has been formulated without disturbing odors, as many aftershaves do. Indeed, this product has made many customers satisfied; even women who have used it as a primer can testify that it is a reliable product.

Moreover, the stock of three bottles is unbeatable, and you get a stock that lasts much longer than you would expect. Nivea is, without a doubt, a trusted brand, and this product, for such a great price, will not disappoint.

7. Baxter of California Aftershave Balm

Almost all Baxter of California products seems to be very popular with a large number of men.

They even made our exclusive lists of the best lotions for men and the ten best soaps for men, and this excellent aftershave balm is no exception.

One of the best aftershave balm for men and top-rated aftershave products on Amazon, this incredible alcohol-free aftershave balm is one of our favorites.

It comes in a 4 oz tube that I appreciate because the tube makes it easy to squeeze out every last drop of balm, unlike the glass bottles that can be cumbersome.

With natural ingredients such as tea tree oil, this post-shave balm helps soothe, nourish, and heal your skin.

The part we like the most is the addition of menthol, which provides an incredibly pleasant cooling effect that almost immediately eliminates all feelings of irritation.

Baxter of California after shave balm has a unique formula that is thicker than most, meaning that a small tube will last you for many months.

The scent is subtle and lasts relatively long, so it will be clear to use this aftershave with perfume.

But the scent is pleasant, if not (classic ’ aftershave. Lime and menthol make this such a refreshing and uplifting aftershave to use.

You’ll be cleansed and protected feel: ideal for anyone who has mentally created a barrier between shaving and healthy, pain-free skin.

Because it has received excellent reviews from our tests and the great reviews it has received from countless Amazon customers, you can feel confident that you will receive a high-quality product, supported by Baxter’s reputation for superior shaving products.

8. Lather Wood Shaving Co- After Shave Balm

The first thing that strikes you about the After Shave Balm from Lather and Wood is that it is thicker than other balms: although it is not an exaggeration. But it has a texture that is more buttery than lotion, and it is non-greasy, non-sticky, and easy to apply.

You will also notice that it is a perfect aftershave.

There are many high-quality aftershave balms on the market, but the aftershave balm from Lather and Wood is at the top of the list thanks to the many benefits. And it is, for example, the best aftershave for sensitive skin out there.

For men with sensitive skin, an aftershave that does not burn and does not irritate the face after shaving is a must. The foam and wood foam balm is alcohol-free and contains coconut oil: naturally moisturizing, antifungal, and antibacterial. In contrast, Jojoba oil is included to control the natural oil production of your skin.

It also contains vitamin E, an antioxidant with anti-aging properties. The other ingredients are rosemary leaf extract, organic neem oil, and witch hazel (no alcohol).

Users find it a balm that cools the skin naturally without drying it out or leaving an oily residue. Again, when an aftershave balm dries out your skin, it is because it usually contains alcohol, which this balm is not.

The foam balm with foam and wood is described by some as unscented, while others notice a slight sandalwood scent.

Although made in small quantities, a bit of the balm from Lather and Wood goes a long way, with some users saying that a bottle can last up to eight months.

9. Truefitt Hill Trafalgar Aftershave Balm

Those in the know are usually aware that the Brits tend to dominate the world of high-quality shaving products.

From straight razors to shave soaps, pre-shave oils, etc., British shaving products remain a step ahead of most of the rest of the world.

Still, there’s only one British shaving company that can claim to be the Official Shaving Line of the British Royal Family—and that’s Truefitt & Hill.

So, if you want to experience what it feels like to be a king, there’s nowhere else to look.

In truth, we probably could have included several different Truefitt & Hill products on our list of best aftershave for men. Still, in the end, we decided to go with the aftershave balm that’s part of the company’s Trafalgar line of shaving products.

This balm contains aloe vera and lanolin to provide hydrating, soothing, and nourishing effects to the skin, guaranteeing it will leave your face feeling smooth and comfortable.

However, this is another product that does contain a small amount of alcohol, so it may not be the best choice for those whose skin is dry.

There are trace amounts of alcohol in this aftershave, meaning it doesn’t lend itself to be used by anyone with mainly dry skin.

Aloe vera, lanolin, and the absence of parabens mean it’s an option for sensitive skin types thanks to their soothing and cooling properties.

Overall, this is an outstanding aftershave balm, but it does come with a slightly higher price tag than most, as you can expect to pay around $50 for a 3.4-ounce bottle.

In truth, it doesn’t provide any better nourishment or skin protection than many of the cheaper products on this list. Still, if you’ve got the extra cash to spend, you’ll likely find it well worth the price.

10. Lucky Tiger Aftershave and Face Tonic

Lucky Tiger is a leading name in men’s shaving and care products and produces various types of aftershaves.

But for our money, the original Lucky Tiger Aftershave and Face Tonic is the choice of the nest.

The labeling is more like an old medicine from ancient times, but this aftershave is produced here in the former US, more specifically in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

The 8 oz bottle is made of plastic, so you can be sure that if it falls off the counter, it won’t break into a million pieces of broken glass on your table in the bathroom.

Witch hazel is an excellent astringent that helps strengthen and tighten the skin.

It also contains chamomile, aloe vera, calendula, and a variety of other ingredients. This product ensures that your skin feels relaxed and refreshed, while the added vitamin A helps restore the skin after shaving.

It is alcohol-free, making it suitable for people with dry or sensitive skin.

A man by the name of Benjamin Clarke began to make this aftershave as his characteristic scent for his hairdresser’s shop.

Ben was an amateur scientist who tried many recipes before deciding on them (the essences of which are still aftershave forms.

As a scientist, Ben wanted to create an aftershave that would suit everyone. This tonic can be used by anyone, although the driest skin is likely to have an alcohol tint because it has a hint of alcohol.

This is an exceptional splash after aftershave at a very reasonable price.

Based on the ingredients, it is, in principle, suitable for all skin types.

Of course, an alcohol-based aftershave may be preferred for various reasons, which is not the aftershave for you.