Skip to Content

Best Aftershaves for Men: a Grooming Guide to Soothing Shaved Skin (2024)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

best aftershaves for menYou should choose an aftershave that calms and soothes your skin after shaving, while preventing irritation and ingrown hairs.

The best aftershaves for men contain soothing ingredients like aloe vera, chamomile, and vitamin E for sensitive skin.

For preventing ingrown hairs, look for aftershaves with salicylic acid or glycerin.

Top picks include Proraso’s menthol eucalyptus lotion, Art of Shaving’s balm, Jack Black’s cooling gel, classic bay rum splashes, and Nivea’s sensitive balm.

Taking care to moisturize after shaving can transform a painful routine into a revitalizing grooming experience.

To truly master the art of the close, comfortable shave, it helps to learn more.

Key Takeaways

  • Aftershaves containing soothing ingredients like aloe vera, chamomile, and vitamin E can calm and soothe skin after shaving, while those with salicylic acid or glycerin help prevent ingrown hairs.
  • Top aftershave picks include Proraso’s menthol eucalyptus lotion, Art of Shaving’s balm, Jack Black’s cooling gel, classic bay rum splashes, and Nivea’s sensitive balm.
  • Aftershave’s key benefits include calming irritated skin, preventing ingrown hairs and razor bumps, acting as an antiseptic, soothing skin, and exfoliating and refreshing the complexion.
  • When selecting an aftershave, consider your skin type – sensitive, dry/dehydrated, or oily/acne-prone – and choose a formula with appropriate ingredients to address your specific needs.

5 Best Aftershaves for Men

We’ll start by introducing five top-rated aftershaves for men, ranging from invigorating lotions to soothing balms that provide post-shave relief. These carefully selected products cater to various skin types and needs, ensuring a comfortable and rejuvenating experience after every shave.

1. Proraso After Shave Lotion Menthol Eucalyptus

Proraso After Shave Lotion forView On Amazon
Proraso’s After Shave Lotion Menthol & Eucalyptus is a revitalizing pick-me-up for your skin after a close shave.

The menthol and eucalyptus collaborate to alleviate irritation.

The formula’s alcohol-free, paraben-free, and silicon-free composition ensures it won’t dehydrate your complexion.

Apply this cooling elixir post-shave for an invigorating sensation that leaves your face feeling rejuvenated and prepared to face the day.

Its classic barbershop scent also evokes a nostalgic touch, transporting you to a bygone era of expert grooming.

Proraso’s aftershave is a trusted choice for men seeking a swift skin recovery after their morning routine.

Best For: Men with sensitive skin seeking a refreshing aftershave.

  • Calming menthol and eucalyptus reduce irritation
  • Alcohol-free, paraben-free, and silicon-free formula prevents dehydration
  • Classic barbershop scent provides a nostalgic touch
  • May not be suitable for very sensitive skin
  • May not provide enough hydration for dry skin
  • Scent may be overpowering for some

2. Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm

The Art of Shaving After-ShaveView On Amazon
The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm is a luxurious post-shave treatment that soothes and hydrates your skin.

Formulated with natural ingredients like aloe vera and vitamin E, this balm calms irritation and replenishes moisture after the rigors of shaving.

Its lightweight, non-greasy texture absorbs quickly, leaving your face feeling refreshed and revitalized.

Whether you have sensitive skin or simply want to pamper yourself, the Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm is a sophisticated choice that will elevate your grooming routine.

Treat your skin to this indulgent balm and experience the difference in comfort and smoothness.

Best For: Men looking for a luxurious post-shave treatment to soothe and hydrate their skin.

  • Soothes skin after shaving
  • Replenishes moisture to dry skin
  • Revitalizes and conditions skin

3. Jack Black Cooling Post Shave Gel

Jack Black Post Shave CoolingView On Amazon
The Jack Black Cooling Post Shave Gel is an invigorating and soothing option for men with sensitive skin.

Infused with aloe vera, menthol, and chamomile, this alcohol-free formula cools and calms irritated skin after a close shave.

The lightweight gel texture absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy residue.

Simply apply a small amount to your freshly shaved face and neck, and let the natural botanicals work their magic.

This post-shave essential helps prevent razor burn, nicks, and ingrown hairs for a smooth, comfortable finish.

Treat your skin right with the Jack Black Cooling Post Shave Gel.

Best For: Men with sensitive skin.

  • Cools and calms irritated skin
  • Absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy residue
  • Helps prevent razor burn, nicks, and ingrown hairs
  • Not available in a fragrance-free option
  • May not be suitable for all skin types
  • Can be expensive

4. Bay Rum Aftershave Splash

Bay Rum Aftershave Splash forView On Amazon
The Bay Rum Aftershave Splash is a classic choice that delivers a revitalizing and invigorating experience after your shave.

Crafted with a blend of spices, citrus, and bay leaves, this splash imparts a warm, woodsy aroma that evokes the tropics.

The formula is free of synthetic chemicals, instead relying on natural ingredients like glycerin to rehydrate your skin.

As soon as you apply it, you’ll feel an instant cooling sensation that soothes any irritation from your shave.

With its vegan, paraben-free composition and 100% lifetime guarantee, the Bay Rum Aftershave Splash is a reliable grooming essential that will leave your skin feeling smooth and revitalized.

Best For: Men looking for a classic, revitalizing aftershave splash.

  • Natural ingredients
  • Instant cooling sensation
  • Vegan, paraben-free
  • Not available in a larger size
  • May not be suitable for sensitive skin
  • Scent may be too strong for some

5. Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm

Nivea Men Sensitive Post ShaveView On Amazon
Nivea Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm is the perfect antidote for skin that’s been put through the wringer.

This alcohol-free formula deftly soothes and hydrates, leaving your face feeling refreshed and revitalized.

Enriched with vitamin E, chamomile, and witch hazel, it calms irritation and redness while locking in much-needed moisture.

Sensitive gents, take note – this balm is your new best friend.

Massage it into clean, freshly-shaved skin and let it work its magic.

You’ll be left with a smooth, comfortable complexion that’s ready to take on the day.

Trust Nivea to deliver the soothing relief your skin craves.

Best For: Men with sensitive skin prone to irritation and dryness

  • Soothes and moisturizes sensitive skin
  • Fights irritation, burning, and dryness
  • Enriched with Vitamin E, Chamomile extract, and Witch Hazel extract

Benefits of Aftershave

Benefits of Aftershave
You’ve just experienced the invigorating ritual of a close shave, but don’t neglect the essential aftershave step. A high-quality aftershave product can alleviate irritated skin, prevent ingrown hairs and bumps, and safeguard against infection with its germ-fighting properties – all while exfoliating and revitalizing your newly groomed complexion.

Calms Skin After Shaving

Aftershave’s primary benefit is its ability to calm and soothe skin after the rigors of shaving. Its moisturizing ingredients like aloe vera and vitamin E hydrate and nourish, while anti-inflammatory properties reduce redness and irritation. The healing properties of ingredients like chamomile and witch hazel can even help speed up the recovery of minor nicks and cuts.


Prevents Ingrown Hairs and Razor Bumps

Prevents Ingrown Hairs and Razor Bumps

Many aftershaves contain ingredients like salicylic acid or witch hazel that help prevent the formation of ingrown hairs and razor bumps. These soothing, antibacterial, and anti-inflammatory benefits work to hydrate your skin and minimize irritation after shaving. However, be mindful of the alcohol content, as too much can dry out your skin and exacerbate the problem.

Acts as an Antiseptic

Aftershave’s antibacterial properties help prevent infection from nicks and cuts, while soothing irritation and reducing redness. Ingredients like glycerin, witch hazel, and aloe vera work to treat inflammation and promote healing. Menthol provides a cooling sensation that leaves your skin feeling clean and revitalized after a close shave.

Soothes Skin

Aftershave’s soothing properties come from ingredients like aloe vera, chamomile, and menthol. These calm irritated skin and reduce redness after shaving. Avoid alcohol-based aftershaves if you have sensitive skin, as the alcohol can cause a stinging sensation. Instead, opt for balms and lotions with nourishing ingredients like shea butter to hydrate and soothe.

Exfoliates and Refreshes Skin

Some aftershaves contain mild exfoliating agents that help slough off dead skin cells, leaving your complexion feeling invigorated and refreshed. Look for aftershaves with:

  1. Salicylic acid to gently exfoliate and unclog pores.
  2. Glycolic acid to promote skin renewal.
  3. Lactic acid to smooth and brighten the skin.

This post-shave exfoliation helps prepare your skin for the day ahead.

Choosing the Right Aftershave for Your Skin

Choosing the Right Aftershave for Your Skin
When selecting an aftershave, it’s essential to contemplate your skin type to prevent irritation and attain the intended results. From delicate skin that necessitates mild, calming formulations to oily or acne-prone complexions that derive benefits from astringent components, the appropriate aftershave can avert razor burn, alleviate post-shave discomfort, and foster a salubrious, revitalized appearance.

Sensitive Skin

If you have sensitive skin, steer clear of aftershaves containing alcohol, which can cause irritation and dryness. Instead, look for alcohol-free formulas with soothing ingredients like:

  • Aloe vera to calm inflammation
  • Chamomile to reduce redness
  • Vitamin E to nourish and hydrate

These gentle aftershaves will leave your skin refreshed without any burning or stinging.

Dry or Dehydrated Skin

If you have dry or dehydrated skin, seek out aftershaves with nourishing ingredients like castor oil, vitamin E, and avocado oil. These will help replenish moisture and soothe irritation. Chamomile and eucalyptus oil also provide calming benefits for sensitive, dry complexions. Steer clear of alcohol-based formulas, which can exacerbate dryness and redness.

Oily or Acne-Prone Skin

For oily or acne-prone skin, choose aftershaves with astringent properties like witch hazel or menthol to help control shine and prevent breakouts. ] These formulas are lightweight and non-greasy, effectively disinfecting while avoiding clogged pores. Proraso’s Moisturizing & Nourishing After Shave Lotion and Geo F. Trumper’s Aftershave in Spanish Leather are excellent options for managing oily, acne-prone skin.

  1. Look for alcohol-based splashes or tonics to disinfect and tighten pores.
  2. Avoid heavy, creamy balms which can exacerbate oiliness and acne.
  3. Apply a lightweight, non-greasy aftershave lotion to hydrate without clogging.

Preventing Razor Burn

Preventing razor burn starts with choosing the right aftershave. Look for soothing ingredients like aloe vera, panthenol, and chamomile to calm irritated skin. Avoid harsh astringents and alcohol-based formulas, which can exacerbate sensitivity. Instead, opt for a gentle, hydrating aftershave balm or lotion to nourish your skin post-shave and prevent unsightly razor burn.

Preventing Ingrown Hairs

To prevent unsightly ingrown hairs, look for aftershaves containing exfoliating agents like salicylic acid or glycerin.

These ingredients help slough off dead skin cells, allowing hair to grow freely.

Beardbrand Utility Oil, with its blend of beardsap extract and grapeseed oil, also soothes and softens skin to discourage ingrown hairs.

Acetylsalicylic acid and black pepper can further aid in exfoliation and hair growth.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How long does aftershave fragrance typically last?

As the old adage goes, Good things come to those who wait. Aftershave fragrance typically lasts 3-6 hours, but you can reapply for lasting potency.

Can aftershave be used as a cologne replacement?

You can use aftershave as cologne sparingly, but they’re not ideal replacements. Aftershaves prioritize skincare over scent potency. For longer-lasting aromas, invest in proper fragrances designed specifically as cologne.

What are the differences between aftershave and cologne?

Like a harmonious duet, aftershave and cologne differ in timing and intent. Aftershave soothes post-shave irritation; cologne awakens your senses with an alluring, lingering fragrance signature.

How often should aftershave be reapplied throughout the day?

You should reapply aftershave sparingly—once after shaving. Its effects usually last all day, so additional applications aren’t necessary.

Can aftershave be used on sensitive skin without irritation?

Can’t handle that tingling sensation? You bet sensitive skin can use aftershave! Look for alcohol-free, soothing formulas with ingredients like aloe vera for irritation-free radiance.


Venturing through the maze of optimal aftershaves for men, the trail to a comforted, revitalized visage beckons your perceptive investigation.

Utilize the potency of nature’s ointments and the most recent preparations to mold your post-shave regimen into a rejuvenating experience.

With a customized approach, you’ll conquer the art of appeasing irritation and preventing ingrown hairs, embracing the pinnacle of grooming excellence.

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is a published author and software engineer and beard care expert from the US. To date, he has helped thousands of men make their beards look better and get fatter. His work has been mentioned in countless notable publications on men's care and style and has been cited in Seeker, Wikihow, GQ, TED, and Buzzfeed.